ASW0005iol marked as #lens and modeled ( definitely not a lens )

• by JasonJason

  
  
  
  

  Model results for ASW0005iol: definitely not

  Posted June 17, 2013 10:31 AM

• by Tom_Collett scientist

  You've got a funny definition of Plausible here! It definitely isn't a lens. Sorry.

  The red thing is a star. The red is not centred in the middle of the 'arc'. The 'arc' has a color gradient across it (needs to be all one color if it's a lensed source). Your lens model doesn't predict the arc's shape and size seen in the real image. There is no counter image where predicted.

  Sorry to be so negative, but we need to be calling this a 'definitely not'.

  Edit: I see you've updated your original post - much better wording now!

  Posted June 17, 2013 12:37 PM