Modelled Candidates 2013
-
by psaha scientist
There are now models for a small but growing number of lens candidates. Lens Model FAQ Let's use this thread to keep track of them, until we can grow a proper index.
Suggest four categories:
- Convincing when the model looks like a pretty good fit to the lens -- leaving little doubt that it is a lens.
- Plausible if the model looks like it's on the right track, but needs improvement.
- Uncertain when the modelling was unsuccessful, or doesn't look right. (Not a lens?)
- Complicated when the system does look like a lens, but the modelling software has difficulties with it.
But feel to propose another system if you have a better idea.
Any implied grading applies only to the candidate and the software not to the heroic human doing the modelling!
Posted
-
by psaha scientist
Convincing
Plausible
- ASW0001c3j
- ASW0000x1l
- ASW0003bit (psc) = pre-spacewarps candidate
- ASW000234o
- ASW0000sfo
- ASW0000mxp
- ASW00014sd
- ASW0002fqt
- ASW0002g35
- ASW0002dx7
- ASW0005hvt
- ASW0003pj1
- ASW0002ta6
- ASW0002494
Uncertain
Complicated
- ASW0001e2j (psc)
- ASW00056pq
- ASW0003q47
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002g35: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000564: Plausible
* Model results for ASW00025bm: Convincing
* Model results for ASW0003img: Plausible
* Model results for ASW00051ld: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0005gvn: Complicated
*Model results for ASW0005ire: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000cn1: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0004b90: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0003pj1: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0003pj1 with additional minima: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0002u9p: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW0000a6f: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW00001bx: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW0002494: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0002ta6: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0005hvt: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0005hvt with added minima: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0002dx7: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0002we3: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW0002fqt: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0005dxd: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW0001b4j: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000rl3: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000sfo: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000mxp: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000mxp flipped: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000ad9: Plausible
* Model results for ASW00014sd: Plausible
* Model results for ASW00048c0: Uncertain
* Model results for ASW0003ls1: Plausible
* Model results for ASW0000eud: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason in response to psaha's comment.
Which way do you want them posted, like the first post and last or the 2 middle posts?
Posted
-
by Capella05 moderator
I think the middle two are best - so we can keep track of modeled candidates without being distracted by images 😃
Carry on creating separate threads for your models and linking them here 😃
Posted
-
by psaha scientist
A thread for each candidate under Science Board / Objects is pretty convenient for discussion. We can look at the pictures, maybe try to improve a model and so on, one object at a time. This thread can then be like an index of models.
Posted
-
by robert_gagliano in response to psaha's comment.
I would like to suggest an alternative classification scheme ;>)
Grade for the likelihood that the object is a lens:
A=I'd bet my life
B=I'd bet your life
C=I'd bet your life and you should worry.Posted
-
by Tom_Collett scientist in response to robert gagliano's comment.
That's hilarious! I like it.
Posted
-
by psaha scientist in response to robert gagliano's comment.
The CASTLES survey came up with that one. Was quite a few years ago, though.
Posted
-
by JasonJason
*Model results for ASW0002a7a: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004o2e: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0001k0p: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00025sz: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00048ls: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002cu8: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002b29: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00046a9: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003xo6: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results of ASW0002ly7: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00055mm: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results for ASW0004ws9: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW0004ws9: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004kg7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002457: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00030q1: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003e3q: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003dxc: Uncertain
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00030ys
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0005cl2: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000412m: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000dx3: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
*Model results for ASW0004ziw: PLausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003pwm: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000b76: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004106: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004rs8: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
*Model results for ASW00045mb: plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0001yw2: Plauaible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000348j: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003xan: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
Model results for ASW0003nzk: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003oh1: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004pbi: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00059a7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
*Model results for ASW0003uzj: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00031go: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004i4b: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00057ip: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000018e: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0001kv0: PLausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003n5d: PLausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003iql: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004kh7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
*Model results for ASW0004i6u: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00048kl: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model for ASW0001j22: seems Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Remodel results for ASW0001kv0: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00025tl: PLausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0001h1w: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000i3o: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000316k: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0005iol: definitely not
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000090m: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003er8: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002ih7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0001eyn: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results
* Model 2 results
* Model 3 results
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004bf7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004zqw: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003r2w: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00020iq: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004id9: Plausible
Model 2 results
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results for ASW0001m2r: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW0001m2r: Convincing
Model 2 has higher pixel depth giving a more convincing modeling
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00023e3: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004hr1: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000get: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002zbd
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004dv8: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 Results for ASW0000id5: Plausible
* Model 2 Results for ASW0000id5: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00043j0: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004fna: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004zgf: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002e4w: Complicated but plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00042d9: somewhat Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004ijz: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004oy7: Complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004i23: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003raj: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0005c4y: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00058s2: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00025rt: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002dbh: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00032t2: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002elx: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00020hq: Plausible
Posted
-
by Tom_Collett scientist
I've had a go at modelling ASW00024id
http://mite.physik.uzh.ch/data/001750
I'd say this one is pretty convincing.
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004fgb: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004vor: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002w6w: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00024id: Convincing
Posted
-
by Thomas_J moderator in response to JasonJason's comment.
Nice work 😃
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results for ASW00050xz: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW00050xz: Uncertain
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003lo2: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000017u: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000x8n: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00037pp: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00057z9: which are complicated
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00059cd: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004a8z: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004dc1: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00056od: Convincing results
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004ey1: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000od9: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000sgy: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results for ASW0005fz6: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW0005fz6: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000326k: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003q62: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004rj2: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004c5w: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00000kv: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000587x: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002j7m: Uncertain
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003q00: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000fet: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000yv8: Convincing
#SA2 Known Lens Candidate
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0003oj7: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00042lz: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0005exg: convincing
#SA121 Known Lens Candidate
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000b1s: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00018cx: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000092a: Convincing
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004iye: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW0004iye: Plausible
* Model 3 results for ASW0004iye: Plausible
* Model 4 results for ASW0004iye: Plausible
* Model 5 results for ASW0004iye: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* model results for ASW0004p3c: Plausible
Posted
-
by c_cld
Result Nr 2224 for ASW0001i1v could be plausible (i.e. the model not the real system! 😃 )
Posted
-
by Capella05 moderator
ASW000asp - plausible, view here
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0002p7c: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0004zqh: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000lhy: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000e7t: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW000358m: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW00040b3: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model results for ASW0000x64: Plausible
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* Model 1 results for ASW0001i1v: Plausible
* Model 2 results for ASW0001i1v: Plausible
* Model 3 results for ASW0001i1v: Plausible
Posted
-
by psaha scientist
Another model for ASW0003bit which looks convincing.
Posted
-
by c_cld
ASW0003dq7 the 1st example of real lenses in the Spotter' guide
http://talk.spacewarps.org/#/boards/BSW0000004/discussions/DSW00006bm
Posted
-
by JasonJason
* model for ASW0005nq1: plausible
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
ASW0007228 SL2SJ141917+511729 model 7079
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
ASW00061d2 7619 ; or
7653ASW00015mc 7696 & 7699 two sources lensed
Posted
-
by c_cld
Spreadsheet of SpaghettiLens models input/output images about some of my "probable candidates" 😃
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by Capella05 moderator
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by Capella05 moderator
A slight adjustment on C_cld ASW000453b (Hope you don't mind!) 8497
Posted
-
by c_cld
@Capella05 It's a pleasure to get a feeling of fitting in 😃
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
sim quad ASW00028k4 011466 a bit difficult at modeling and fitting a quad accordingly
ASW0000o6h 011485 small arc accross edgeon
Posted
-
by c_cld
models compilation Doc updated
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
Posted
-
by c_cld
ASW0009io9 011827 great and convincing
Posted